Saturday, August 23, 2008

Due Wednesday, 9/3

Read II Samuel 11-12. Be careful to get the correct book and chapters -- you should be reading about King David. Then listen to this song and write a blog comment on what you get out of it. (Remember that King David was credited with writing the Psalms, the greatest songs of Judaism.) The lyrics are here.

23 comments:

Anonymous said...

I think the song is simply portraying how David fell in love with a married woman, and he was willing to even sacrifice one of his friends to get what he wanted. I also believe it is trying to say how faith can change a man completely.

emA said...

I thought the song did a really good job explaining the David and Bathsheba story. It explains how David couldn't control himself, and did things that he knew God would not approve of. But then later how he became very faithful to God, and became a better person.

A.K.S said...

In the first verse I thought the minor fall was when God killed David's first son, and the major lift was when David captured the royal citadel of the Ammonites. The first half of the second stanza is obvious in meaning, but I dont understand the second half. Also I thought the last verse that she does not sing tells of how David killed Bathsheba's husband out of jealousy that Uriah found her first.

Anonymous said...

I think that david fell in love with the women even if it wasn't what God wanted. And he didn't do what God had told him. But later he did earn God's trust back and became a better person.

Anonymous said...

This song explain the David and Bathsheba story from the point of view of david. David sees Bathsheba and wants her more than anything so he sacrifices everything to get her. He has his friend killed because he got to her first and he is jealous. this song also tells us that God was not happy with David when he did this but then later on God forgives David and David goes on to become an amazing person.

Anonymous said...

I think the song explains the David and Bathsheba story well. The first couple lines of the song seems to say that if you do not care about god you will fail. It describes how the king failed. It says that its hard to fall in love and find that right person out there because there is always faith. I kinda got lost in some parts, but i think I understood most of the song.

eds123 said...

First of all, I love this song. Secondly, I believe that it does a great job of explaining how David's choice to fall for Bathsheba had some major consequences in the end. The part that was the most true to the Bible story was when it said that "he saw her bathing on the roof", and in Samual II it says "From the roof he saw a woman bathing." Also, when the song talks about "shooting somebody who outdrew you" this might refer to the fall of Uriah.

Anonymous said...

This song is telling the David and Bethsheba story, but i think it also tells how love can change a person for good and/or bad. David killed Uriah to win over Bethsheba, but in the end he realizes what love really is.

bbell=] said...

I thought that the first verse was directed towards GOD. Saying, David played music to please GOD, but GOD wanted more than just music. The second verse I found was directed to David, saying he couldn't resist her because she was so beautiful. The kitchen chair and cutting of hair I found was bringing up Samson and Delilah. The third verse I believe was David saying he'd loved before, and he knows it sucks. Also saying he was alone before he found Bathsheba. The fourth verse i understand is completely sexual. I don't think i need to explain it much. The fifth and final verse is saying that all love teaches is to be mean to the person that is mean to you. And then goes on to state that all his love has been broken and he hasn't found true love.

I think the entire song was saying that David should have trusted in the Lord God to give him Bathsheba, but instead he killed a man to get her and he disappointed the Lord.

mbrien said...

I think the song is like a chapter in a diary portraying the story of Batsheba and David in a simpler and more poetic way throughS David's eyes. It shows how he would do anything to get this woman, even if it meant killing a friend but in the end it shows how the desires of a man can be overcome by faith

MKF said...

I really like this song and now I know what the lyrics are about. They tell the story of David and Bathsheba. David "saw her bathing on the roof", referring to Bathsheba. He falls in love with Bathsheba and wants her for himself so he kills Uriah. David angers God and is punished but in the end David realizes he has sinned and God forgives him.

Anonymous said...

The lyrics to the song are definitely from David's point of view. He first sees Bathsheba washing herself on the roof, and he immediately falls in love with her. He sacrifices everything to get her for himself, and is punished by God. But David asks for God's forgiveness and he is granted.

JK said...

The lyrics to this song are very literal and metaphorical at the same time. The words portray the story in a very raw manner that makes David's story gripping and very real. However, when the song talks about cutting hair, it reminded me of Samson (similar situation to David). In the fourth verse, God is talking to David. Reminding him of what he's done to Bathsheba, and how it was. However, God does not speak in a condescending tone.

"Love is not a victory march It's a cold and it's a broken Hallelujah"

Anonymous said...

This song tells of david being faithful to God and always wrote praises to him but God wanted to test him to see how faithful he would be. SO Davis sees bathsheeba bathing and ended up falling into temptation and was not proven faithful beacuse he slept with a married man's wife, and then killed her husband. the write of the song is saying that Now david's songs songs and praises have become broken hallaljahs because he had sinned and his faith was broken because of falling in love with this woman.

rsox0407 said...

this is jeff.the song kind of talks about how his faith changed him and the song also kind of refers to how david falls in love with a married women which is a problem. david wants the woman so bad he would kill a friend yet his faith prevails

ZHerron said...

I like the first part of the song with references to music. When she talks about the "secret chord," she mentions the "minor fall, the major lift." In terms of music, minor means lower and major means higher; A minor is lower than A, and A major is higher than A. However, I think the song means something else. Someone in class asked why King David was not punished more seriously for some of the horrible things he did. As C.S. Lewis wrote, "No amount of falls will really undo us if we keep picking ourselves up each time." That is to say, that even if we sin, if we truly repent and attempt to correct ourselves, we will be forgiven.

Anonymous said...

David betrayed God by falling in love. Later he was able to regain God's trust and become a better person.

atp said...

this is a great song. honestly i think there are many ways you can look at this song. religious or not! I think it is telling the story of David and Bethsheba.It tells it almost word for word in more of a poetic way. He tell how he fell in love even though he new it was wrong and was willing to admit to his sins and suffer his punishment that god gave him.

Anonymous said...

I think the song is saying that a great king fell for a woman he couldn't have. And shouldn't have. It also talks about his trust in God and how he tries to earn God's forgivness.

jojo014 said...

i think the song tells the story of david and bathsheba pretty well. It talks about how david fell for her "You saw her bathing low on the roof
Her beauty in the moonlight overthrew you". It also shows how god forgave david for what he did. Although what david did was bad it explains in the song that it ended up being a good thing.

Z THO said...

This song does a good job of telling the story of david and bathsheba. It also shows how love can lead to good things as well as bad things.

Anonymous said...

What really stuck me about this song was the changing relationship between God and David. They had a complex relationship. God loved David, but David let his emotions get the best of him. God was hurt when David sought out Bathsheba and killed Uriah. Yet, David still worshiped the Lord after his transgressions. The fourth verse shows God's reaction and emotions towards David.
"There was a time you let me know
What's really going on below
But now you never show it to me, do you?
And remember when I moved in you
The holy dove was moving too
And every breath we drew was Hallelujah"

eyoung22 said...

i think the purpose of the song was to show how greed and want of a good man with power can change his whole life to a life that is unjust and even then that if you ask for forgiveness and admit your wrong you can be forgiven