Sunday, September 14, 2008

Assignment for Thursday, 9/18

Read Analects of Confucius at
http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/china/philo/confuc.htm#Confucius,%20The%20Teacher,%20and%20Person
Write two 100+ word essays on the above blog on Confucius' Analects. I will assign the particular analects you need to write on, so don't get started on your essays until we go over the assignment in class. You may get started reading Confucius, though.

PPT presentations for the China unit will be on Wednesday 9/24 and Thursday 9/25.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

(6:20) on religous life
I believe that in this analect, Confucius is trying to say that we need to respect the supernatural but not become obsessed with it, just be satisfied with it. I also believe he is trying to illustrate the point that sometimes thing are just better left unknown. Confucius is trying to say that we shouldn't get ahead of ourselves and to just slow things down and appreciate them for what they are. Also, he is saying that we shouldn't do things just to get
praise and rewards for them; noting should be expected: we should do them because we are supposed to.



(12:5) on religous life
I believe that in this analect Confucius is trying to state his "sliver rule" by basically saying that if you want respect, you must give respect. For example, if you expect to be acknowledged by a person higher up in society than you were, you must first give them respect. We must respect and live by the very strict rules of propriety. Also, I think that Confucius is saying that some things up up in the air, left for fate to decide, while at the same time only your relationships can depend on you to work out the way you wish them to.

JK said...

Analect 12:7

Basically, Confucius says in the government the most important needs are (in this order):
1. "confidence of the people"
2. "food"
3. "armament (weapons)"

1. It's questionable whether he is talking about people having confidence in themselves, or people's confidence in the government. From my perspective, he speaks of people's confidence in the government. The Qin Dynasty fell, because people started mistrusting the government's laws/philosophies. People might say Confucius is talking about the people having confidence in themselves, but if the people gain too much security in their own opinions and thoughts of the proper way to rule, the government will not have strong and stable control (hence the "Time of Warring States). Therefore, I say Confucius refers to the people's trust (confidence) in the government. It the people don't support the government, the state cannot succeed.

2. Although Confucius uses many metaphors, I believe he uses "food" literally. Of course, crops are crucial in any civilization to it's economy and health. Also, he predicts listeners will be skeptical about choosing food, which is cruicial to life and health, over "confidence of the people" and says, "There have been deaths from time immemorial, but no state can exist without the confidence of the people." This explains why I think Confucius literally meant edible food (crops).

3. Confucius says armament is the least important. Nevertheless, he might surprise learners by saying armament is important at all. As far as some know, Confucius didn't support war. He always talked of peace and morality. But I say Confucius isn't dumb or naive. He knows that other surrounding countries might not adopt Confucian philosophies, and might attack China. This most likely wouldn't have happened, but they needed to be prepared to defend themselves with weaponry. However, learners quickly find out that Confucius didn't highly regard armament; he says he would give up weapons first before food or trust.



Analect 12.11
Bottom line: Fulfill your own tasks and responsibilities. Don't try to take on another's role or job.

jgawrys said...

ker and junnie both have well-written and thoughtful entries. Check plus for both.